Wednesday, August 15, 2012

Why the SEC is the Best Conference in College Football

I recently read an article discussing why the SEC is not as great a conference as people crack it up to be (here).  While being enjoyable to read, I can't help but disagree with nearly all of it.  Most of it is cherry-picking facts to support the argument while ignoring many other obvious ones.  I won't attempt to tear the whole thing apart as that really does nothing more than refute one opinion that is based on a shaky foundation as best.

The major concept that this article chose in its attempt at bashing the SEC is the their records against other BCS conferences is mediocre since the inception of the BCS.  For the sake of argument, I will agree with that, and trust that the numbers he found were accurate in portraying such.   However, let's note that the argument  of the SEC being the best conference has not existed since 1998 when the BCS was constructed.  The argument surrounding the BCS is one far more recent than that, pretty much since they went on a streak of six National Championships in a row.

Here are the SEC records against teams from other BCS conferences dating back to the 2006 season when Florida won the first of these National Titles:
  • ACC (33-21) - .611
  • Big East (11-10) - .524
  • Big Ten (12-9) - .571
  • Big 12 (15-7) - .682
  • Pac-12 (8-5) - .615
  • BCS Conferences (79-52) - .603
Conference realignment within the BCS conferences has been minimal through 2006-11 with only one game against Nebraska this past season being played with a team in its new conference.  These numbers show a more dominant SEC compared to the aforementioned article.  The Big East no longer has Miami or Virginia Tech giving them a winning record, and the Pac-12 has been far less dominant in recent years compared to the first half of the last decade where USC and Oregon were making frequent BCS stops.  Ironically, it is the Big East that are closest to breaking even with the SEC although that relied a lot on a West Virginia team that has since moved on to the Big 12.

Nonetheless, it proves that over the last six seasons, no BCS conference has had a winning record over all the other conferences except the SEC.  Even more ironic in my opinion, is that the Big 12 is probably the only conference that could possibly challenge the SEC for supremacy over the last past couple of seasons, but they have by far the worst record against the SEC.  You can argue that the SEC isn't "as good" as some make them out to be, but you can't use out of conference records and suggest the SEC isn't the best because they are the only ones to prove it back holding winning records against the five others.  On conference records along, no one has held their own at all except maybe the Big Ten and Big East at times, but surely no one would argue in their favor that they are better.

Now preseason polls are something I have long disagreed with having.  In fact, I would suggest that polls should not be voted on until October once some games have been played.  However, it makes the point that conferences that see a biased in their favor in the preseason automatically have a better chance at playing for a National Championship, or a BCS bid, so it is worth looking at here.  Let's take a look at the number of preseason top 10 and 25 teams dating back to 2006 to see how they compare to the rest of college football (using the USAToday Coaches Poll):

  • ACC:  Top 10 - 6
  • Big East:  Top 10 - 3
  • Big Ten:  Top 10 - 11
  • Big 12:  Top 10 - 15
  • Pac-12:  Top 10 - 6
  • SEC:  Top 10 - 16
Those totals don't really mean anything until you look at the total number of available teams those conferences put forward.  For instance, the Big 12 should have more preseason berths than the Pac-12 because the Pac-12 played with less teams over the course of the 2006-2011 seasons.  Let's call them Conference Chances (CC):
  • ACC:  6 seasons x 12 teams = 72 CC
  • Big East:  6 seasons x 8 teams = 48 CC
  • Big Ten:  5 seasons x 11 teams + 1 season x 12 teams = 67 CC
  • Big 12:   5 seasons x 12 teams + 1 seasons x 10 teams = 70 CC
  • Pac-12:  5 seasons x 10 teams + 1 season x 12 teams - 2 (USC banned) = 60 CC
  • SEC:  6 seasons x 12 teams = 72 CC
Simply dividing the number of top 10 appearances from each conference by the total number of CC gives you a percentage of how many conference teams show up in the preseason top 10 year to year.  For example, the ACC:

[(6 Top Ten Appearances) / (72 CC)] = 0.083 or 8.3% of the ACC teams

 This results in the following:
  1. SEC - 22.2%
  2. Big 12 - 21.4%
  3. Big Ten - 16.4%
  4. Pac-12 - 10.0%
  5. ACC - 8.3%
  6. Big East - 6.3%
This does suggest that the SEC gets a preseason biased in the polls, but not a significantly larger one than say the Big 12.  Ignoring just how ridiculously stupid preseason polls are, these percentages really make perfect sense since they go primarily by the results of previous season.  If the SEC keeps winning championships, they are likely to see that percentage increase.  Meanwhile, based on the out of conference records mentioned above, it should really be no surprise that SEC teams are moving more and more towards the top.  I am not surprised the Big 12 came in second in this, but was shocked how close they were to the SEC.  Meanwhile, the top three percentages here account for 11 of the last 12 teams to play for a National Title, including all the National Champions.  I'll acknowledge that doing this method with the top 25 favors the SEC more than the other conferences.  Granted, I think ranking 25 teams by a human is pointless.  Can you really remotely measure the 17th best team versus the 23rd?  The SEC dominates this part of the preseason polls because of parity.  As far as a top 10 preseason spot goes, I really see no significant biased towards the SEC compared to the Big 12 or even the Big Ten.

Speaking of parity, the SEC is really the only top conference that shows parity year to year instead of team to team.  This isn't to say Vanderbilt or Kentucky have any shot, but the conference has produced not only numerous conference champions over that time, but four different National Champions.  This is different than the Big Ten where Ohio State was the lone dominant team over that period, similar to Texas/Oklahoma in the Big 12, and USC/Oregon in the Pac-12.  Trying to pick a conference champion in the SEC ahead of the season is far more difficult than selecting a Virginia Tech or Oregon for their respective conferences.

One last thing, the opposing article I've referenced mentioned favorable bowl matchups for them.  Obviously, the majority of bowls are played in the south because going to Washington, Idaho, New York, Pennsylvania, and Ohio is not really appealing in January.  The SEC likely gains a bit of a homefield advantage with that, but I find that slightly blown out of proportion.  On the other hand, it is worth looking at the SEC bowl matchups.  Let's assume the SEC and Big Ten both send two teams to BCS bowls which is business as usual, this leaves:
  1. SEC Champion to National Championship Game
  2. SEC #2 to BCS Bowl
  3. SEC #3 to Capital One Bowl vs. Big Ten #3
  4. SEC #4 to Outback Bowl vs. Big Ten #4
  5. SEC #5 to Cotton Bowl vs. Big 12 #2
  6. SEC #6 to Chick-fil-a Bowl vs. ACC #2
  7. SEC #7 to Gator Bowl vs. Big Ten #5/6
  8. SEC #8 to Liberty Bowl vs. C-USA #1
  9. SEC #9 to Music City Bowl vs.  ACC #6
  10. SEC #10 to BBVA Compass Bowl vs. Big East #5
  11. SEC #11 to Independence Bowl vs. ACC #7
After the couple of BCS bids, the first two matchups make sense.  Both are again Big Ten teams, but both matchups place the 3rd and 4th place teams against each other which seems fair.  After that is where is gets a little hairy.  The Cotton Bowl pits the 5th best SEC team against the 2nd best Big 12 team.  This year that was Arkansas to beat Kansas State pretty handily.

Next you have the runner up in the ACC facing an SEC team that finished in the middle of it's conference.  This year, the ACC sent two teams to BCS bowls which left the #3 ACC team, Virginia, who got ran over by the #6 SEC, Auburn.  The #7 SEC Florida, pulled one out of Ohio State.  The point is that for all the favorable homefield advantage locations, the SEC is generally pitted against teams that finished higher in another conference.  More often than not, they beat them.

Anyone can argue how dominant one conference is versus the others.  Opinions will vary on style of play, weather conditions, scheduling, etc.  However, I see no way of debating that the SEC is not the top conference in college football.  I didn't agree with them sending two teams to the National Championship Game, but that is hardly their fault so much as a very faulty system.  On the flip side, it was the SEC that was left on the outside looking in for 2004 when an undefeated Auburn team was passed over.  I honestly don't see how you could argue any team was better than the team crowned BCS National Champion since the SEC began it's run in 2006.  You can argue a Boise State or TCU deserved a shot at them, but I challenge anyone who would be willing to put their next paycheck on one of those teams instead of the one that was eventually crowned.

Some last little facts to toss out there.  USC and West Virginia are the only two non-SEC teams to play in more than two BCS games since the 2006 season and post a winning record.  Since the BCS inception in 1998, only five teams have winning records in National Championship games, all of them are SEC teams.  The question I would pose, if not the SEC, then who?

Saturday, August 4, 2012

Nice Night for a Walk

While not a record, it is still an impressive feat and he's a New York Met, so what do you expect from me?  Outfielder Mike Baxter has quietly put together some nice numbers for a bench player this season.  He has started in just over a dozen games this season, being used mainly as a pinch-hitter, and late-inning defensive replacement.  In his few at-bats this year (71 in total), he has hit .310 while posting an OBP over .400 and a SLG just under .500.  While he lacks power, one career home run (last season), he has made a habit of hitting doubles.  In fact, as of tonight, he has only 9 singles compared to his 11 doubles and 1 triple.  Fairly anomalous if you ask me, but that isn't what this post is about.

Of course a Golden Sombrero is when a play strikes out four times in a game.  I'm not quite sure what the opposite of that is, a Silver Zapato(?), but Baxter likely acquired it.  Tonight, Baxter got a rare start for the Mets, and after five plate appearances, he did not record a single at-bat.  This is because he drew not four, but five walks on the evening.

I don't know how often players have drawn five walks in a game, but I believe it is fair to say that it isn't often.  Only two players have drawn more than five walks in a nine-inning game: Jimmie Foxx of the Boston Red Sox in 1938 and Walt Wilmot in 1891 with the Chicago Colts (now Cubs).  Two others accomplished the feat in 16-inning games.

Anyway, for a player who will not receive a lot of recognition until he finds his way into the lineup regularly, here is to you Senor Baxter.

Thursday, July 26, 2012

Lucky 7-6

Just a quick one tonight.  For those not paying attention, the Philadelphia Phillies beat the Milwaukee Brewers on Wednesday by a score of 7-6.  For those paying even less attention, the Phillies also beat the Brewers on Tuesday by a score of 7-6.  Last, for those who have more of a life than myself and don't need to remember baseball scores beyond 72 hours, the Phillies beat the Brewers on Monday by a score of 7-6.  I have no knowledge of any such statistic or record, but I would be curious the last time two teams produced the same game result with the same score over three consecutive games.  I have to wonder if it is the only time to occur with that many runs scored each game.  Lucky 13 maybe?  If that isn't entertaining enough, I suggest tracking down the video of Milwaukee outfielder, Carlos Gomez who thought he hit a leadoff home run, and ran 315 feet around the base paths before discovering it was a long foul ball.

Monday, July 23, 2012

Better Choice than the Death Penalty

Sorry to my Penn State friends, but I feel the NCAA for once did right by stepping up to the plate and handing down appropriate punishments.  I firmly believe the punishment should be very severe.  This was not an SMU, Miami, or Ohio State where players were benefiting from receiving money or goods.  However, none of those situations ever resulted in individuals being abused and hurt in irreversible ways.

While I am sure most readers already know the penalties being enforced, let's note them here since I will try to touch on each of them later.  Penn State has received a fine of $60 million dollars, a four-year postseason ban, a scholarship decrease of 20 for the next four seasons, and all wins vacated from the 1998-2011 seasons.  Note that this was not the "Death Penalty", but in my opinion equally just to all sides.

The Death Penalty would have meant no football in State College for at least one season (possibly more).  On one hand, the penalties for the football team are likely worse as they are than had the Death Penalty been issued.  In general, they will be very hard pressed to be competitive with a schedule that includes Ohio State, Wisconsin, and Nebraska annually, and even if they are, it will be for not since they are not allowed for play for a conference championship or in bowl games.

On the other hand, allowing the program to continue to schedule and play football games means that the punishment does not branch all the way down to the local level of State College.  By that, I mean the restaurants, stores, bars, etc. of central Pennsylvania will still be able to operate to higher patronage on game day.  The local economy is not the the major focus here, but they should be unharmed by this decision.  Furthermore, the fans of State College can continue to support the program as they choose fit.  They are not forced  to sit on their hands and watch Pittsburgh, Temple, and the Big Ten play every Saturday with no true interest.  For those reasons alone, I commend the NCAA for finding a ruling that punished the program, but not those who are not directly connected to it.

Many argued for the past few weeks that the punishments were not going to help the victims, and that the rest of the world was just out for blood.  I don't agree with that line of thinking.  A murderer being sentenced to life in prison is not going to bring a victim back to life.  As I mentioned in the first paragraph, the acts committed by Jerry Sandusky, and indirectly by others in the program are irreversible.  You can't simply avoid punishment because those acts can't be undone.  Punishments are consequences for previous acts.

Nevertheless, the NCAA and Big Ten did find a way of doing right by the victims in one way.  The NCAA fined them $60 million which must be paid over the course of five seasons ($12 million per).  Meanwhile, the Big Ten will be handing over Penn State's share of the Big Ten bowl revenue for the next four seasons (estimated to be at $13 million over that time).  That breaks down approximately to a loss of $15 million per season from 2012-2015, and $13 million in 2016.  Obviously, that is a large amount of change to any one of us, but for an athletic program that profited $15 million this past year, and $18 million the previous year, this is certainly doable.

If either group wanted to go for the kill with revenue, they could have booted Penn State from the Big Ten, or prohibited them from broadcasting their games.  So long as they still receive their Big Ten television contract, this is a survivable penalty.

Much of the rest of the sanctions affect the athletes (past, present, and future) of Penn State.  Let's not suggest this is the end of the world for any of them, and that the penalty only affects them as many have done.  The vacating of wins from 1998-2011 could be said to affect everyone who was part of the program for those years.  I don't believe that.  The players and staff who were not involved still received a free education (players), or a paycheck (staff).  They can still talk about their time at Penn State, and the bowl games they participated in.  To those individuals, they won those games, and no one can take away their stories.  Penn State has not won or tied for any conference championships over that time, so they are not being wiped out of the record books for anything along those lines.  If anything, this affects only the legacy of Joe Paterno.  He is no longer the winningest coach in football.  It seems more fans are upset about losing that title for Florida State's Bobby Bowden above all else.

Obviously, the scholarship sanctions will directly affect the number of future athletes who can be offered to play at Penn State, or the number that will choose to play through this period.  Therefore, it is the current athletes that lose the most.  However, the NCAA has granted their release, and they can move to any program they wish that will accept them.  For those who choose to stay, they lose a chance to play in bowl games or for any titles.

Now for anyone who denounces that only the current players are being hurt by this, let's look at it from a different perspective.  In the past couple years, big time programs like USC, Ohio State and Miami have been hit by scandals.  Those programs along with Penn State are known for grabbing top recruits from across the nation.  No one could disagree with any of this.  However, during all those other scandals, how often was it noted that only two programs never had any NCAA violations?  Those two programs were Stanford and Penn State.  So when a top recruit was deciding between Penn State and Ohio State, can anyone suggest that Penn State did distance itself from the Buckeyes by mentioning how squeaky clean they have stayed over the year?  Fact of the matter is, Penn State benefited from athletes as well as non-athletic students by maintaining such an image.  In reality, that image should have vanished over a decade ago when the first report came about.  Therefore, I do not buy into the notion that only the current players are being hurt by the NCAA sanctions.  In reality, these players were hurt by the lies told by the Penn State athletic department, not the NCAA.  The penalties are always going to affect the current program the most, but you can't simply avoid punishments because of that.

It is sad that college football has grown to such proportions that it can become a bigger priority than the safety of human beings, especially children.  Nevertheless, that is what happened, and that same lack of priorities would be repeated if such a program went on without receiving any consequences.  Penn State has won many games over the past 13 seasons because of it's untarnished image, great recruits, and large revenue stream.  It is impossible the measure the differences that may have occurred if action was taken sooner.  The current players, the fans, and the legacies are punished with these sanctions, but that does not mean the true victims should be forgotten.  It is not simply a loss for Penn State, but a loss for all programs, athletes, and fans when we lose a grip on such priorities.

Friday, July 6, 2012

Reggie Being Reggie

In a recent interview with Sports Illustrated, Reggie Jackson did what he does best (aside from striking out).  He spews his opinions as if it's gospel.  I believe what endears many fans to respect baseball greats like Willie Mays, Hank Aaron, and countless others are not only their abilities on the field, but their abilities to remain quiet if not respectful towards everyone else.  Not Reggie.  If he wants the attention, he will say whatever he pleases in order to get it.

This isn't anything new.  After all, he claimed he was the second more important black in the game of baseball behind Jackie Robinson.  He has claimed to be "the best in baseball", and suggests that he was the most important cog in for the New York Yankees teams of the late 70s while everyone else was nothing more than a minor role.  True or not (I suggest not), going on a soap box for yourself while suggesting the captain of your team is a negative influence doesn't necessarily win you any points in my book.

In his latest rant, he suggested that Hall of Fame players Gary Carter, Jim Rice, Don Sutton, Phil Niekro, Kirby Puckett, and Bert Blyleven do not deserve to be in the Hall as if he is Cooperstown's Ambassador to the rest of the world.  To be fair, I don't believe all of those players deserve to be in the Hall of Fame, but to suggest none of them belong is ridiculously far-fetched.

Gary Carter:  I am extremely biased towards Carter being a Hall of Famer due to him being my favorite player of all time.  However, I never quite understood the arguments against him.  I never understood how it took so long for him to get in.  Carter was as stellar a catcher as they was after Johnny Bench until the age of Ivan Rodriguez.  He was not simply a catcher who could put the bat on the ball.  dWAR, a statistic used to define how many runs a player saved over the course of a season and career is a remarkable 25.4, good for 14th all-time.  The only catcher rated higher for defense is Ivan Rodriguez.  All of that does not even take into account that Carter was a hitter.  WAR (Wins Above Replacement) is defined as the number of wins a player contributes to a team over what a replacement-level (AAA or AAAA) would.  A quick scan of the records shows that only one catcher has ever led this category for a season: Gary Carter in 1982.  Furthermore, Carter finished in the top ten for eight consecutive years (1978-1985).  I myself can't find another catcher who finished in the top ten more than five times throughout his entire career.  Note that this list includes Johnny Bench, Yogi Berra, Ivan Rodriguez, Roy Campanella, Mike Piazza, and Carlton Fisk.  Fact of the matter is, Carter is a clear cut Hall of Famer.  It likely took a few years only because home run totals and batting averages matter most to voters who were voting during the steroid era, on a career that took place in a pitcher's era.

Jim Rice:  Jim Rice I would likely make the argument against being in the Hall of Fame, but would have to admit he is borderline if not.  He was a very good hitter over the course of his career, but added nothing in the field.  His bat was as good as anyone between 1977-79, but otherwise, it was good at best most seasons.  He did show brief glimpses of Hall of Fame prowess in 1983 and again in 1986, but beyond that I believe he was an All-Star at best.  Being a Red Sox left fielder, he reminds me of an inconsistent Manny Ramirez who had a shorter career.

Don Sutton:  Sutton is not a Hall of Famer in my book.  He is merely the product of longevity, and nothing more.  Sutton had an above average career from the start, and was somewhere between good and excellent between 1970-77.  An eight year stretch like that is nothing to scoff at, but the era was not exactly in favor of hitters much.  After 1977, he really only had one great season (1980), but otherwise was a decent starter most years.  The thing is, his career continued until 1988 meaning much of the second half of his career was average.  Longevity should count for something, but not everything.  Voters and fans attach themselves to the ability to win 300 games at the Major League level.  It's a great achievement, but it's a stat for pitchers that mean more than it should.  Sutton took 23 seasons to reach a win total of 324.  He spent 16 seasons with the Los Angeles Dodgers who  had winning records in 13 of those year, including briefly dominating the National League in the late 70s.  More often than not, the teams Sutton was on after the Dodgers including the Astros, Brewers, and Angels were very good teams.  Now, he was part of those teams and deserves credit.  However, the second half of his career I believe he was a #4 starter in an era that only used four starter.  There is only one other player with less than Sutton's 324 wins, but more than 300 who pitched more seasons, and that is Phil Niekro.

Phil Nierko:  Niekro is part product of longevity, and that generally should be expected of a knuckleball pitcher.  However, I find his career more impressive.  Niekro is a pitcher who was consistently among the top ranks in pitchers when it came to complete games, shutouts, and innings pitched from 1968-80.  Like Sutton, if he didn't stick around until the late 80s, he never would have reached 300 wins.  While Sutton pitched for the often National League favorite Dodgers, Niekro spent the majority of his career with the Milwaukee/Atlanta Braves (1964-1983).  In all those years, the Braves only finished higher than 4th in their division three times, and won their division only once.  I could be wrong, but Niekro may be the only pitcher ever to get Cy Young votes while losing 20 games.  In 1979, he went 21-20 for a Braves team that lost 94 games.  The two previous seasons he won 35 games combined while pitching for teams that combined for 194 losses.  A great argument as to why wins are not a good measure of a pitcher.  If Niekro had been pitching for the Dodgers, 350 wins could have easily be attainable.  The question remains, could 400 been?

Kirby Puckett:  Puckett is a sad story of a guy who had a very good career end early due to health, only to see his admirable image end early because of numerous indiscretions, and last his life as much too early an age due to a stroke.  Ignoring the off the field antics, I have issues being for and against Puckett.  He was a terrific hitter, pushed the Minnesota Twins to two World Series titles in his short career, and was still very good at the time he lost his sight in one eye.  On the flip side, his defense was vastly overrated in my opinion despite the number of Gold Gloves he won, and images of him in the 1991 World Series.  In fact, if Puckett ever deserved to win a Gold Glove, it should have been during his rookie season of 1984.  I'm not sure why good hitting combined with a guy who can dive for a few fly balls, and pull back a home run or two translates into a Gold Glove over a guy who can cover the field much better.  Moreover, while it is sad seeing a player forced to retire early due to health, I feel such a player should truly have been elite (aka Sandy Koufax) to be considered for the Hall of Fame.  Puckett may have been close, but I don't think he was necessarily elite.  Going back to dWAR mentioned earlier, Puckett often ranked below a replacement level player, even when he was "winning" Gold Gloves.  He was a terrific singes and doubles hitter, not a huge surprise playing his entire career in the Metrodome.  He didn't carry a tremendous amount of speed, power, nor did he draw many walks.  He could put the bat on the ball, and when teaming up with the hard turf of the Metrodome, he looked like a Hall of Famer.  However, take him on the road, and while still very good, the difference of more than 50 points in his batting average argues against it.  Sorry, but no Hall of Fame for Kirby.

Bert Blyleven:  Despite the 22 seasons he has to his name, Blyleven is one of the few players that wasn't both consistent, yet excellent who may deserve in the Hall.  Perhaps a better way to state that is that he was extremely consistent at being good, but wasn't excellent for more than a handful of seasons.  Unlike Sutton and Niekro, Blyleven for teams that were generally middle of the road.  For any good teams he played for like the Pirates of the late 70s or Twins of the mid 80s, he played for just as many bad ones like the Cleveland Indians and California Angels.  His win total shows this well with a record of 287-250.  Ironically, Nolan Ryan may have had the biggest hand in keeping Blyleven underrated for the Hall of Fame.  After all, Ryan had blown the career strikeout record
 out of the water.  Meanwhile, Blyleven retired third all time for career strikeouts with numbers not terribly worse than Ryan's.  Despite much argument against Blyleven in the past, I have come around to supporting his induction even though I will be quick to point out that he is one of the very few who was never elite.

That is my take on those players anyway.  Reggie Jackson is a Hall of Famer, even if his personality leaves something to be desired.  Despite what he may enjoy implying about others, Jackson is in fact an extremely overrated Hall of Famer himself.  Often, he is lumped with greatness because he played for the Yankees, or hit over 500 home runs.  I hope most have learned to let those types of achievements go by now.

Remember what I said about longevity?  Jackson hit his final 99 home runs in the last five years of his career.  Over those five seasons, WAR suggests that a replacement level player would have outperformed him.  Despite the fact that he still had some pop in his bat, his teams, the Angels and Athletics would have been better off without him.  Not surprising when he .223 or less in the majority of those seasons.  Does 464 home runs still scream Hall of Famer the same way?  Meanwhile Jackson was a horrible outfielder.  I would go as far to say that while he may have been an elite hitter with the New York Yankees, he was not an elite player.  With Oakland and Baltimore, his skills as the plate were so good, he was still an elite all around player despite his poor performance in the field.  By the time he went to the Yankees in 1977, his hitting still outweighed his fielding, but not so much he was elite in my book.

Many of his accolades relate to his playoff performances, after all, he was Mr. October.  Yet once again, people relate too much to home run totals.  Yes, his 1977 and 78 postseason performances were ridiculous.  He had plenty of other good series as well.  However, there are many other players I would want on my team before Reggie Jackson in the postseason.  Give me a Steve Garvey from that same era who was a far better hitter and fielder in the postseason.  Hell, I'll take a Derek Jeter today.

We could all debate any of the names mentioned above whether they belong in the Hall of Fame or not.  In my opinion, a Hall of Famer doesn't get much more overrated than Reggie Jackson, even if he is better than some of the aforementioned.  Nonetheless, it is the classlessness that only Jackson can offer to suggest that these guys don't belong in his company.

Saturday, June 30, 2012

Hitting Like It's 40 Years Ago

The month of June comes to an end tonight.  We're a couple games shy of the halfway point of the Major League Baseball season.  So many times, it is easy to jump on absurd patterns halfway through a season, only to see another abnormal second half going the other way that causes things to even out.

Nonetheless, it is hard to grasp just how odd things look this year.  One of only two MLB franchises never to win a pennant holds the best record in the National League.  A 37-year old knuckleball pitcher is on pace to win the Cy Young.  Meanwhile, the league as a whole is hitting the worst it has in 40 years at a combined .254.

Four individuals are currently batting over .350 for the season.  This may not sound too odd, and to be fair, we are less than halfway through the season, but fact of the matter is the last time four individuals hit over .350 in a season was back in 2000.  Perhaps more remarkable are the players doing it, or at least the top three.

Currently, the Mets' David Wright leads the league with hitting by sporting a .361 batting average.  While Wright had a few stellar years early in his career, most know his production has dropped in recent seasons.  In fact last year he hit a mediocre .254 for the year, and his on-base percentage of the last two seasons have been lower than his current batting average (.354 and .345).

Next we have Phillies catcher Carlos Ruiz who prior to this season sported a career batting average of .265.  Yet this season, he has been pretty much the only offense to show up in Philadelphia, especially as Chase Utley and Ryan Howard fought back from injuries.  Ruiz has hit 11 home runs with a stunning OPS of 1.000 for the season, a remarkable feat for a player who never hit more than 9 home runs in a full season before now.  All the while, he has posted an excellent .357 batting average.

Next we have Melky Cabrera who resides on his fourth team in as many seasons.  In Cabrera's case there was at least a sign of better things to come, even if it was small.  Cabrera was a .265 lifetime hitter following the 2010 season in Atlanta.  However, last year in Kansas City, he did eclipse .300 for the first time in his career.  Nevertheless, in his first seasons with the San Francisco Giants, he his hitting a tremendous .354 on the season while leading the league in hits with 109.

The lone other playing hitting over .350 would be former first base MVP, Joey Votto.  In fact, Votto is currently the only player in the top ten for batting average who finished in the top ten last season (10th).  This is not a category that rotates in all fresh new faces each year, so one has to wonder where the Miguel Cabrera's, Adrian Gonzalez's, Michael Young's, Jose Reyes, and Ryan Braun's of the world are.

Perhaps the more telling aspect of this is that I mentioned initially, this season is on pace to be the worst for hitting (batting average) in forty years.  The batting average across the league this year is .25388.  Despite a couple close calls in 1988 and 1989 (both years finished a hair above .254), no batting average has been worse until you go back to when the league hit a paltry .244.  It leaves for little argument to suggest that the game is still favoring hitters as it has the previous couple of decades leading to now.

It's worth noting that last season, MLB only hit .255.  2011 saw the lowest OPS and runs scored per game since 1992, and 2012 is right on the heels of 2012.  This of course could change by the end of the season, but for now it is safe to say the pattern still holds that we are headed into another small ball era.

Thursday, June 14, 2012

Did I Miss Anything?

As mentioned a couple weeks ago, I was going to be away for awhile on various trips, leaving me less time to post anything.  Well, it seems I picked a bad few weeks to fall out of the loop here.  The Los Angeles Kings won their first ever Stanley Cup over my New Jersey Devils on an arguable call (Kings did deserve to win overall), the Heat led by LeBron James came back against the Celtics to land in the NBA Finals a second straight year, and no-hitters appear to be contagious in Major League Baseball.

Of course the biggest thing to me was the no-hitter by New York Mets pitcher Johan Santana against the St. Louis Cardinals.  As you may have seen in a previous post, I had given the Mets the Curse of Nolan Ryan for trading away the Hall of Fame pitcher in the 70's only to see him pitch a record seven no-hitters in his career.  Meanwhile, the Mets went over 8,000 games without accomplishing the feat, closing in on a Philadelphia Phillies' record for the longest streak without one.  However, that run abruptly came to an end on June 1st as Santana went the distance against the St. Louis Cardinals in an 8-0 victory.

Santana was helped along the way, not only by his teammates, but by one poor call by an umpire midway through the game.  Former Met, Carlos Beltran hit a line drive down the left field line ruled foul.  Upon reviewing replays, the ball did clip part of the foul line and therefore should have been ruled fair, likely resulting in an extra-base hit.

It wasn't the worst call in sports by any means, but it was the wrong call.  Some might say the Mets didn't deserve the no-hitter because of it, but I don't think those people appropriate weigh all the individuals calls that go into the course of one baseball game, or a sporting event in general.  It's easy to focus on the ones that make the difference such as the Carlos Beltran foul ball, or Jim Joyce robbing a perfect game and no-hitter from Armando Galarraga by ruling a player safe at first that was clearly out.

However, before you can truly deem that these bad calls alone were the deciding factors, you would need to really analyze every single play/pitch for the game.  My memory certainly isn't 100% for Galarraga's game, but I seem to recall him seeing quite a few pitches called in his favor that might not be considered strikes every other day of the week.  On the flip side, how often to pitcher's throwing a no-hitter end up on the wrong side of a call when they give up a walk, or a called strike goes unnoticed only to see the hitter get another chance?

I don't believe many umpires (Angel Hernandez being an exception) having an agenda against a team to truly make calls constantly one way, and in the grand scheme of things it usually balances out.  That said, I'm a Mets fan, so perhaps I'm biased on Santana accomplishing the feat and breaking the Mets run.  However, if you don't believe my theory that all evens out, look no further than last night's Mets game when they visited the Tampa Bay Rays.

In the first inning with two outs, the Rays B.J. Upton hit a ground ball to third baseman David Wright.  Wright tried to barehand the ball, dropped it, and Upton reached safely.  The play was deemed an infield hit although from watching it, the majority would clearly argue it was an error.  Mets pitcher R.A. Dickey recorded the final out of the inning, and the whole thing seemed inconsequential.  Well, that was until eight innings later when Dickey was still on the mound behind a Mets 9-0 lead.  Dickey didn't give up another hit, and in fact didn't walk a batter all night.  Had the play been ruled an error, the Mets would have recorded a no-hitter in Tampa Bay last night.  In the end, Dickey was credited with a one-hitter in a 9-1 victory.  The lone run coming from a David Wright throwing error in the ninth and two passed balls by Mike Nickeas, and being unearned.